Do I need a mentor? Here is my thought.

Posted on 01 March 2010 by Shane Mac

After 20 some years of thinking I needed mentors to tell me where to go I find myself wondering if those same mentors actually mute many other people’s dreams before they ever get started or even try. After reading Jun Loayza and Ryan Paugh’s posts about mentors I decided to share with you the comment I left on Jun’s blog. Here is my comment and after that go read his post.

Actually, I think if I would have had a mentor I would be 25 steps backwards on where I am today. For 20 something years I have had amazing parents, friends, and coaches tell me the path that lie ahead. Is that where I am at? Nope. All of them told me what awaits, what I ‘needed’ to do, and where I ‘had’ to go, yet that is not where I am, who I am, or what I have done. My boss at work 6 months ago told me ‘you have a lot to learn son’ and yes, yes I do, but 6 months later I sit with him planning a new strategy around social and blogging.… Lesson: We all have a lot to learn.

Like yourself Jun, I fought the urge to be content with the lifestyle I was told to lead and if I had listened to the ‘mentors’ I would still be in Illinois probably working at Caterpillar trying to climb some ladder that didn’t really exist. I would be sitting at a computer knocking out a checklist of one specific job all day.

I could have had all of that lifestyle if I would have listened to what you described as a mentor. But now, all of those mentors call me and say the same thing, ‘wow you are up to some amazing shit. I wish I would have done that stuff.’

While I listen to that comment on repeat in my life lately I always have the same thought.

It is exciting, humbling, and gets me all stoked to wake up everyday, but the only reason I am where I am today is because I didn’t listen to the people who you would describe as a mentor. I could see the path no one else saw and that my friend is why I like teammates and not mentors. I know they all are/were trying to help but it is those small comments that can kill dreams, vision, and stop most people in their tracks from doing what they truly believe. Mentors, though not even realizing it, probably kill more dreams/visions than they create. They provide security and mitigate risks because that is usually the path they have lead (at least in my life.) Bad? Not at all. Just what most know.

Awesome post Jun and I stop, think, reflect, smile, and say thanks so much for running alongside me in the recent months. If you ever need a teammate in this game then you let me know because you have been here for me already on a number of occasions. Here for ya.

-Shane

What makes me an expert? Nothing. I am just a guy who enjoys helping people find career paths that they didn’t know existed. I strive to help people ask questions and think about things a little differently. Life and Careers are about asking the right questions. Please ask us anything, or just subscribe to the The Squab feed via RSS or Email to receive notifications of new posts.

This post was written by Shane Mac, founder of thesquab.com.  Read more about himfollow him on twitter, join him on Brazen Careerist. or become a fan of the squab on facebook,

Photo Credit: Mike 52

  • Interesting point of view. I've been meaning to read this post since it showed up in my RSS feed and only just got around to it.

    My only issue is, for me, a mentor is more someone who is doing what you want to be doing - not so much a friend, parent, or teacher. They are someone who will share what they have done and inform you of opportunities you may not hear about otherwise. Anyone who thinks they know your goal better than you is not a mentor.

    A mentor, in my mind, is someone who wants to help you achieve your goals - whatever those goals may be - and will turn out their resources and advanced experience to help you do so.
  • Completely Agree.

    I think it is just how we perceive mentor. Some would say that mentor means a leader and some would say different.

    I think my main message is just find someone who believes in whatever you are doing and don't let someone tell you the 'right' way to do things. 'Right,' in my own opinion, is an opinion.

    Thank you for the comment and how r u?
blog comments powered by Disqus
 

You need to log in to vote

The blog owner requires users to be logged in to be able to vote for this post.

Alternatively, if you do not have an account yet you can create one here.

Powered by Vote It Up